RSS LJ

July 25, 2011

Why I still prefer Twitter (, )

by fluffy at 6:11 PM

I'm just not able to keep any interest in Google+, for the same reasons that I can't keep any interest in Facebook. Having longer posts doesn't necessarily make things better; instead it makes it seem like I really must read everything, which turns it into an overwhelming burden, and inline comments make it feel like even more of a firehose of information. I like how Twitter is a place where I can just share quick simple notions and links to fuller bits of content. I like how the fuller bits of content are hosted on my own site where I and others can find it easily, rather than quickly being buried in piles and piles of comment replies to Felicia Day and Wil Wheaton. I like how Twitter is just a bunch of messages that people pass along and there's no expectation that everything is seen.

I feel like Google+ is in an uncomfortable middle ground between mass-messaging and blogging, with the disadvantages of both but the advantages of neither. I felt the same way about Facebook. Also, the fact that Google has their hands in ALL of my data, with potentially disastrous consequences, makes their overbearing "real name" policy even more upsetting.

Basically, I still miss blogs and don't feel like G+ or Facebook do anything to help communication - they just do what Twitter does, but longer, and with more overwhelming crap to sift through, and an expectation that you do sift through it all.

That said, Hangouts are pretty neat. It would be nice if it were a completely separate product that were based on Jabber or the like, though.

Comments

#14079 Anonymous 07/26/2011 05:38 pm
I agree. I don't think any social network will really replace Twitter for me.

Even my Facebook is mostly just a place for family members to message me and another place to see my tweets. I haven't really done anything on Google+ since getting invited.
#14080 Duke of the Bump 07/26/2011 05:41 pm
Anonymous:
I agree. I don't think any social network will really replace Twitter for me.

Even my Facebook is mostly just a place for family members to message me and another place to see my tweets. I haven't really done anything on Google+ since getting invited.


That was me, got logged out somehow.
#14081 fluffy 07/26/2011 05:50 pm
Yeah, my family can just keep messaging me in email and voicemail and whatever. You want "circles?" How about just making an address group?

</curmudgeon>
#14087 dancing 07/30/2011 03:11 pm "like"
fluffy:
Yeah, my family can just keep messaging me in email and voicemail and whatever. You want "circles?" How about just making an address group?

</curmudgeon>


aw, i really wanted to "like" this comment! haha =P totally hear you even though i do use facebook. mostly to see what it's about and to see how it changes over time though. and wow that person's trouble with google... guess it's not such a good idea to put all the eggs in one basket, huh? (um, i think that's the saying... i have trouble with those american idioms sometimes)...