RSS LJ

January 29, 2012

Laptop ()

by fluffy at 2:00 PM

So my MacBook is well over 3 years old and it's starting to get really aggravating. It's actually still plenty fast, but the original Unibody MacBook seems to have various I/O problems, and I've ended up only using this as a glorified netbook for a while anyway. Meanwhile, OSX Lion is starting to really get on my nerves for a number of thousand-papercuts reasons, while Linux has been getting progressively better and better over the last few years.

So anyway, I've been looking at laptops again and have a pretty short list of ones I'm interested in, but am open to other suggestions as well.

Right now my top contender is the Lenovo ThinkPad X220T. It's fairly lightweight (about 4 pounds), has a convertible tablet screen (multitouch and Wacom) which makes it useful for a lot more things for me, it apparently gets pretty decent battery life (5 hours with the standard battery, and there are additional batteries you can add on to get it much higher). Also, being a ThinkPad it's very well-constructed, and has a decent keyboard and touchpad (and while I'm not a fan of nipple pointers as a primary input it's nice as a backup). On the downside, 4 pounds is probably a bit too much for the tablet to be particularly comfortable, and a 12.9" 1366x768 screen seems positively anemic these days.

In second place right now is the Thinkpad T420s. It's a little lighter than the X220T, has a bigger screen (14" 1600x900), and has a real GPU as an option.

In third place is the X220, which is exactly the same spec-wise as the X220T except there's no tablet functionality and it's quite a bit lighter (under 3 pounds). It seems to be the perfect blend between netbook and laptop (and isn't much more expensive than a netbook, either), but the fact that the X220T exists makes me feel like I could be doing more with something in that form factor. But the plain X220 is definitely better when it comes to having something I'd not mind traveling with.

Other than the three ThinkPads above, I've been looking at a bunch of the various ultrabooks, but many of them suffer from crappy keyboards or touchpads, or are a bit underpowered, or reportedly don't run Linux at all well. And of course now that I know about the X220T I'd really like a convertible tablet, but most of them just plain suck. I just wish it had a bigger screen.

Are there any other systems I should be looking at? I require Linux compatibility (I will probably dualboot with Windows 7 for a while though), Core i5 or i7, I'd prefer to keep it under 4 pounds (and the lighter the better), a good keyboard and touchpad, and a screen that's at least 1366x768 but larger is better, and a Wacom stylus would be a nice plus. Per those criteria, the MacBook Air 13" is actually a really good choice, except I know from experience that MacBook touchpads are hard to get working well under Linux (where multitouch support is still in its infancy and everyone seems to think that tap-to-click is the only thing you need).

Anyway, are there any other systems I should be looking at?

Comments

#14667 mkilly 01/29/2012 07:13 pm
man, I have been absolutely in love with my MacBook Air 13". If the touchpad's no good with Linux, though, that's a real shame. but it's sure responsive, great screen, love the touchpad and the keyboard. no complaints. Core i5.
#14668 fluffy 01/29/2012 07:23 pm
Well, to be fair, I'm not sure if the laptop's trackpad has a problem - I just know that the Magic Trackpad (the Bluetooth version) doesn't work very well with Linux's current multitouch support.

Also, there's a bit of an alternate issue in that Apple's getting a pretty bad humanitarian track record lately, with their suppliers in China. I'm not sure if Lenovo is any better, though. But Lenovo does also put their devices through hell to make sure they won't die if dropped, for example.

Anyway, another reason is that I already have a Mac desktop (which I will probably keep using for a while) but I want something for running Linux (and I guess Windows as well) directly on instead of going through a VM, since I'm trying to get out of Apple lock-in on everything.
#14669 HeuristicsInc 01/30/2012 10:42 am
for what it's worth, i'm happy with my lenovo laptops. my wife's dad used to work for ibm, so we get employee discounts. but i definitely like lenovo better than the dells we get at work. i like the sound of "convertible tablet screen"!
-bill
#14670 mkilly 01/30/2012 02:08 pm
fluffy:
Well, to be fair, I'm not sure if the laptop's trackpad has a problem - I just know that the Magic Trackpad (the Bluetooth version) doesn't work very well with Linux's current multitouch support.

Also, there's a bit of an alternate issue in that Apple's getting a pretty bad humanitarian track record lately, with their suppliers in China. I'm not sure if Lenovo is any better, though. But Lenovo does also put their devices through hell to make sure they won't die if dropped, for example.

Anyway, another reason is that I already have a Mac desktop (which I will probably keep using for a while) but I want something for running Linux (and I guess Windows as well) directly on instead of going through a VM, since I'm trying to get out of Apple lock-in on everything.


Wikipedia lists Lenovo as a Foxconn client, though without citation: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxconn#Major_customers

I'm not so bothered by Apple's patronage of Chinese manufacturing, but I respect the opinion of those who are. Obviously Macs have Boot Camp, and it looks like they can run Ubuntu with good hardware support, but I'm not telling you anything you don't know.
#14671 fluffy 01/30/2012 02:13 pm
I tried setting up a Linux dualboot on my current MacBook and couldn't get anything to work. I have no need for a portable Mac anymore anyway.
#14672 fluffy 01/31/2012 02:59 pm
Anyway, I just ordered an X220T with a bunch of options (docking station, bluetooth, webcam, etc.) and should get it in 2-3 weeks. Yay!