Arbiter Kila Rosha: However, this case has exposed some internal Academy issues with implications sufficiently far-reaching that a declaration of opinion is necessary. Based on the testimonial presented from all parties, we feel that Dean General Tamu Haring has acted irresponsibly.
Rosha: While his intentions were noble, his actions showed a blatant disregard for the safety and sanctity of others and the Scientific Method.
Rosha: This Court also believes that much of the blame rests with Organeer First Class Juni Melrose, who has subjected itself and others to undue stress.
Brin [translating to Kajoshi for Hira]: The Arbiter believes that some blame belongs to Juni Melrose, who has given stress to herself and others.
Hira [Kajoshi]: I see.
Rosha: We recommend it seek psychiatric counseling before it is allowed to return to its research; while science must proceed, it must not be at the expense of our sanity, individually or collectively.
Rosha: Addendum: for violations of Tribunal protocol, Lieutenant Sasha Tzernikov is to serve a period of ten days without benefit of personal translation devices. I hope it finds this fitting.
Rosha: Per standard protocol, anyone may dispute these findings within the next five days, after which all information will be released to the public record. Case 193857 adjourned.
Original script for what eventually became this and the previous comic:
Arbiter: Good morning to you all. I am Arbiter Kila Rosha. I would like to thank you all for your cooperation.
Arbiter: As a disclaimer, I only learned late in the tribunal process that my spouse, Kali Rosha, had any involvement in this case - as broad but as shallow as it appears to have been. I do not believe that my integrity was compromised, and my spouse was neither questioned nor consulted regarding any particulars.
Arbiter: Also, as a representative of the public government, clearly my views do not match with Kali's; our meal-time conversations tend to become quite... passionate. We shall move on.
Arbiter: It is the opinion of this court that Captain Edward Lombard is to be exonerated of all charges leveled against him. Given the circumstances, it is clear he was only doing what was required of him, and that he never placed anyone in any immediate danger, perceived threat aside.
Arbiter: However, this case has touched upon a few other issues. While they seem internal to the Academy, I feel that their implications are far-reaching enough that a Court declaration of opinion is necessary.
Arbiter: Based on the testimonial presented we believe that Dean General Tamu Haring, while acting towards the general good, has done so without regard for the safety and sanctity of others, and his actions have led to the suppression of important research, and possible harm to his subordinates.
Arbiter: This court also believes that Officer Juni Melrose has subjected itself and others to undue stress, and should consider psychiatric counseling. While scientific progress must move forward, it must not be at the expense of our own sanity, individually or collectively.
Arbiter: As an addendum, for transgressions against tribunal protocol, Lieutenant Sasha Tzernikov is to serve a period of ten days without benefit of any personal translation devices. I think you will find that fitting.
Arbiter: All participants will have a period of five days to challenge our findings, after which all information pertaining to this case will be released into the public record.
Transcript
Comments
I'm really sorry