Electric vehicle charging and carbon offsets

One of the reasons that people buy an electric vehicle is to reduce their carbon footprint. Even if you live in an area where electricity is primarily generated by fossil fuel, the amount of emissions that come from generating electricity to power a vehicle is much lower than the equivalent emissions than you get from an internal combustion engine, due to things like carbon capture and the overall economy of scale that comes with power generation. And, of course, many areas are moving away from fossil fuels for power generation to begin with; electricity is fungible and with the increase in renewable sources such as wind, solar, and hydroelectric, electric vehicles' overall environmental footprint will improve along with the electrical grid.

So, of course, one of the more maddening trends in environmental policy of late is the purchasing of “carbon offsets” or “carbon credits,” where polluters spend money on things that will supposedly make up for their pollution. Many of these offsets are a total scam, where the offset is just buying into not making the environment worse (for example, by not bulldozing a forest that was already protected to begin with).

The intersection of these two things is that many of the electric vehicle companies (both manufacturers and charging networks) are selling carbon offsets — against the very same customers who are paying good money to do their part to reduce emissions in the first place. This negates the environmental benefit of electric vehicles, and most EV owners would probably like to know which companies are double-dipping in this way.

This list is not exhaustive, and only covers the manufacturers I could find information about. If anyone has information about other manufacturers and charging networks selling offsets against their customers, please leave a comment with a link to a credible source.

Also keep in mind that even if an EV manufacturer isn’t selling carbon offsets, many of them are buying carbon offsets for the emissions-generating portions of their manufacturing processes so that they can claim their vehicles are truly “emissions-free.” No vehicle is emissions-free, particularly in their manufacturing (and EV battery manufacturing is particularly bad). But fewer emissions are better than more emissions! And over the lifetime of a vehicle, an electric vehicle generates significantly fewer emissions, all factors included, with the average break-even point at around 13,500 miles.

Manufacturers

The following automobile manufactuers sell carbon offsets against their electric vehicles:

Charging networks

The following charging networks sell carbon offsets against their customers:

  • Electrify America (a subsidiary of Volkswagen) (additional info)
  • EVgo
  • Possibly Tesla, although it isn’t clear whether they’re selling carbon offsets against the supercharger network or just against their vehicles

Comments

Before commenting, please read the comment policy.

Avatars provided via Libravatar