Re: More reasons as to why I left the Fediverse Notes
In reply to: More reasons as to why I left the Fediverse
I feel somewhat similarly. I use Mastodon as a not-Twitter (and don’t particularly care for Bluesky), and I have started to embrace PeerTube as a not-YouTube, but the entire architecture of ActivityPub just isn’t a good fit for me. Most of what’s being done with ActivityPub could be much better (and more easily) encapsulated in RSS/Atom feeds, and the lack of identity consolidation is a huge drag, and IndieWeb absolutely does a much better job of separating the protocol from the identity.
I am so very tired of how every time I work on a thing for a specific use case, people come out of the woodwork to try to convince me that I should be building it on ActivityPub, and then they have all this hand-waving about how it gives you “instant interoperability” when some of these systems can’t even interoperate with different versions of themselves, much less other ActivityPub-based applications.
The FEP process is incredibly opaque and arcane and hand-wavey, the “how the fuck do I discover the ActivityPub endpoint from this user’s page” is even worse, and ActivityPub itself doesn’t feel like a very good protocol for many of the things it’s trying to cover. Heck, Mastodon (probably its biggest success story) doesn’t even do a bunch of stuff in keeping with the design of ActivityPub, like how it overloads “subject” to be a content warning, for example.
Following PeerTube or PixelFed or FunkWhale or whatever from Mastodon is a giant mess, none of those platforms can follow Mastodon, and I am constantly failing to see what the supposed advantages of it are over RSS/Atom with simple <link> discovery. Heck, even if ActivityPub were to use <link> instead of whatever ad-hoc per-stack bullshit that ends up emerging, it’d be a huge improvement. But also ActivityPub implementations all seem to be super devoted to the idea of Everything Is Push and Who Cares About Backfilling. Which might be fine for a Twitter-like but it’s abysmal for any of the other things people are trying to adapt it to.
RSS/Atom aren’t universal either, and that’s why Chorus is its own thing. Atom could be closer to being universal if people were better at implementing/acknowledging its various extensions (and if its extension process weren’t also kinda bad), but like. Sometimes it’s okay to define a format that’s specific to the needs of the protocol!
And yeah I also agree with the point of how most of the ActivityPub-based things seem to be based primarily on “let’s rebel against American tech companies, fuck America and all its citizens” instead of “let’s make something that’s better for everyone all around the world.”
(via Jacky Alciné)
